[ He doesn't hesitate in calling her out, but his tone isn't accusatory, either. He states the word as if it's a simple fact: ]

Lie.

[ He keeps his eyes trained on hers for as long as she bothers to look at him, and then continues watching her when she looks away, fingers working slowly. ]

You're after some kind of golden ticket, taking a beating for the witches like you did. Besides. They've made everyone want it, at some point or another.